The alternative
to alternative facts is, of course, real facts. So, in the interest of straight
talk, let’s list a few facts.
1. Fact: Contrary
to the alternative fact repeated often by the GOP, the United States is actually
one of the most undertaxed developed countries on the planet. Among the 35
member countries of the OECD (Organisation for Economic Co-operation and
Development), only four have lower taxes as a percentage of GDP than the US.
Total tax revenue in the United States rings in at 26.0 percent of GDP. The
average among OECD countries is 34.3 percent. I’ll do the math for you. That’s
32 percent higher than the US. The UK is rather low at 33.2 percent. Germany is
at 37.6 percent. Norway, 38.0 percent. Sweden and Finland, 44.1 percent.
France, 45.3 percent. Denmark, 45.9 percent. Of course, these countries provide
health care for all citizens and provide a far better social safety net, even
though the United States spends a far larger percentage of GDP on health care
than these other countries.
2. Fact: The US
national debt is just north of $21 trillion. This bothered the Republicans when
Obama was president. They were so bothered, in fact, that they were preaching
austerity at a time when we needed government stimulus to keep the economy
afloat. Now, however, when we really ought to be reducing the debt, Republicans
don’t seem to care about the debt.
3. Fact: The
Republican tax “reform” is estimated to increase the debt by $1.5 trillion over
the next ten years. The lion’s share of this tax cut will go to corporations
and to the wealthy.
4. Fact: The
wealthy do not need more money. In 1989, the top 10 percent owned 20 percent of
the nation’s wealth. In 2013, their share had risen to 51 percent. They did not
need a tax cut. If they keep raking in an increasing share of income, wealth
will soon be so skewed that the consumer classes will be unable to purchase all
the products corporations need to sell in order to stay afloat, and a rapidly
increasing number of Americans will be dependent on government to survive.
5. Fact: 12.7
percent of US families live in poverty. That represents 43.1 million people. 41
million people struggle with hunger. This number will increase substantially as
wealth migrates to the top.
6. Fact: 35
percent of all adults in the US have only several hundred dollars in their
savings accounts, and 34 percent have zero savings. Even older workers who can
see retirement on the horizon aren’t prepared for it. The median savings for
families whose wage earners are between 50 and 55 years old is only $8,000. For
those who are between 56 and 61, it’s $17,000. In case you hadn’t noticed,
that’s not enough to live a year on. Most of these people will be almost
entirely dependent on Social Security.
7. Fact: Roughly
10,000 Baby Boomers will turn 65 today. On average, that same number will turn
65 every day until the Baby Boom generation is all over 65. An increasing
percentage of the population will be over 65 through 2050 because people are
living longer and the birthrate has dropped. This will put an increasing strain
on Social Security and Medicare.
8. Fact: Our
infrastructure is crumbling. Almost 10 percent of our 612,000 bridges need to
be replaced or repaired. Our airports are outdated and inadequate. Our highways
need maintenance, as do our city streets, our water and sewer systems, and our
electrical grid. We can’t pay for this the way we paid for the Iraq and Afghanistan
wars (with tax cuts).
Conclusion: We
cannot continue funneling money to the top, undertaxing the wealthy and corporations,
building up a massive federal debt, and cutting aid to the poor, the elderly,
and the disabled. The notion that taxes are evil is simple propaganda. Taxes
are how we pay for the things we expect government to do for us.
And let’s deep-six
one other alternative fact. Money that goes to government through taxation does
not simply disappear into a black hole, as conservatives sometimes insinuate.
It is infused back into the economy, which is a much more efficient method of
paying for what we need than borrowing that money.
Thanks for laying these ideas out so clearly. I have heard an number of these "the government is out to ruin us" kinds of statements made. I wonder what it would be like for each of us if the things we said were fact-checked, like some political speeches are. This would be especially interesting in cases where we're in a group of like-minded people and we're a little worked up. I'm sure we'd all learn a lot!
ReplyDelete